
I love telling people about Melon Pan/Melon Bread/メロンパン, and I love eating it, but I’ve been reticent to try to make it.
It’s not made from melon. When I had my first melon pans, I spent a lot of time trying to find melon flavor, to no avail.
So why is it called melon bread? The general consensus is that it’s because it looks like a melon (though you can’t really tell that from my efforts), and if you ask people in Japan, that’s likely what they’ll tell you.
Some might tell you that a foreign baker
As with the history of most food, the origin really isn’t clear.
Anyway, a little bit more about what it is before I jump into the recipe. In short, it’s a sweet bun with a cookie crust (you score the cookie bit, and that’s how you get the lines that make it look like a melon).
The sweet bun, call kashi-pan (菓子パン), is used for lots of different treats, and often has sweet red bean or cream inside. However, it’s unfilled for melon pan.
The recipe I used for the sweet bread came from this website. The ingredients are:
1 3/4 cups bread flour
1/4 cup cake flour (you can substitute all purpose flour by replacing some of the flour with cornstarch, which I did)
1 tsp salt
3 tbsp sugar
1 1/4 tsp instant dry yeast
1 large egg, beaten
3 1/2 tbsp whole milk, at about 85-90F
3 1/2 tbsp water, at about 85-90F
2 1/2 tsp room temperature butter, cubed
As always, I used my mixer. Kneading is probably a good workout, and I could probably use it. But, I digress. Here’s how to make the bread:
1) Combine the flours, sugar, and salt and mix. Now, to be perfectly honest, I’m sure that you can just use 2 cups of all purpose flour.
2) Beat the egg, and add both the egg and the yeast to the flour/sugar mix.
3) Add the milk and water. Mix using the dough hook.
4) Once the dough comes together, add the butter and continue to knead it in with the mixer. It will look weird for a while. Have faith. It will come together.
5) Put the kneaded dough into a bowl and leave it somewhere warm for one to two hours.
I made the cookie crust part of the recipe from the same website, but it just didn’t turn out for me. It crumbled and cracked and, although it adhered to the buns when baked, it just wasn’t flexible enough to cover the bun. So I found a different cookie recipe, from this website, which went better.
The ingredients are:
2 cups plain flour
1 tsp baking powder
3 oz butter
1/2 cup sugar
1 extra large egg
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
And here’s how I made it:
1) Mix the flour and baking soda in a bowl.
2) In another bowl, beat together the butter and sugar.
3) Add the egg and vanilla and mix.
4) Add the flour/baking soda mix.
In my opinion, assembling the melon bread was the hardest part. I’m not gifted with bread dough. Or anything requiring finesse, really.
The quantities for the bread dough and the cookie dough were quite different. The bread recipe was meant to make ten melon pans, the cookie recipe, eight. Put melon pan in general has an expected size, so I figure the recipes were both designed for the same size of melon pan. I ended up dividing the bread dough into ten and the cookie dough into eight, and then I just baked two sweet buns without a cookie crust.
Once the bread dough is finished rising (if you stick a finger in the dough and the hole doesn’t close back up, it’s done), measure it and divide it into ten equal pieces.
Roll those pieces into little balls and let them rest at room temperature for about 15 minutes.
Divide the cookie dough into eight pieces and put them in fridge for a few minutes. After they’ve chilled for a bit (I let mine chill for 5-10 minutes), take them out and roll them into flat circles.
To assemble, place a cookie disc in the palm of your hand, and a bun on top of it seam side up. Wrap the cookie dough around the bun and place it on a cookie sheet. Sprinkle on some sugar and score the top to get that melon look.
Most people say to dip the cookie-wrapped bun in sugar. I had a problem the cookie part falling off when I tipped it upside down (gravity, ya know?), so I just sprinkled sugar on top. It seemed to work.
Let them rise under a damp cloth for about 40 minutes and then bake them at 350F for 15 minutes.
Simple, huh?
They were tasty. And my Japanese friend said she could tell they were melon pan. So the lesson is that I need to practice more. And maybe try out some new flavors.


































